Updated
Striking distance keywords are searches where your page already ranks close to the top, usually position 5 to 20 in Google Search Console, so a modest improvement can put it where people actually click. To find them, export queries and pages from Search Console, keep the pairs with an average position between 5 and 20 and enough impressions to judge, then fix the title, the page and its internal links for the words people searched.
What “striking distance” means
The term covers keywords on page 2 (positions 11 to 20) and the lower half of page one (positions 5 to 10). Both get few clicks for the impressions they earn, because most clicks go to the first few results. Google has already judged the page relevant to the search, which is why moving it up a few places is usually easier than ranking a new page from nothing.
There is no official definition. Some guides use 11 to 20 only, some 4 to 15. The band matters less than the reason behind it, so here is the reasoning for 5 to 20:
- Why start at 5, not 11. Average position is an average. A query showing “11.2” may sit at 7 on some days and in some cities and at 16 on others. Positions 5 to 10 are also on page one but usually below the first screen, so they share the problem.
- Why stop at 20. Beyond 20, the page needs a much bigger change to reach the top, which is a content or authority project, not a quick win.
- Why not positions 1 to 4. Those already get most of the clicks. If one gets few clicks, the issue is the title or the search result features above it, not the ranking; see organic CTR by position.
DirectoryLens uses the same band: its Almost page one report lists searches where the impression-weighted average position rounds to 5 to 20. Its Bigger opportunities tab widens it to 3 to 30 for a longer list.
How to find striking distance keywords in Search Console
- Open Performance > Search results and pick the last 3 months, which gives enough impressions without mixing in old rankings. Turn on Average CTR and Average position.
- Get queries and pages together. The report shows one dimension at a time in its table, and both the table and the export stop at 1,000 rows. For more, use the Search Analytics API with the query and page dimensions (up to 50,000 rows per day per site per search type, per Google’s note on data limits), the Looker Studio connector, or the bulk export to BigQuery. On a small site, filtering the UI by one page at a time also works.
- Filter to an average position of 5 to 20. In a spreadsheet, round the position first, so 4.6 counts as 5 and 20.4 as 20.
- Set a minimum number of impressions. DirectoryLens defaults to 20 impressions for a query and page pair over the dates you pick, and lets you go from 5 to 100. Below about 20 you can’t tell a low click rate from bad luck, and you will spend time on searches almost nobody makes. On a big site, raise it.
- Remove brand searches and
site:queries. Brand searches behave differently; see branded vs non-branded keywords. - Sort by what is at stake. Impressions times the click rate you would get at a better position, minus the clicks you already get. Use your own click rate at position 3, not an industry number; here is how to build it.
/plumbers/austin-tx ranks 9.3 for “emergency plumber austin” with 1,400 impressions and 14 clicks in 3 months. If your pages at position 3 usually get 9% of clicks, the same impressions at position 3 would bring about 126 clicks, so up to 112 more. That is an upper limit, not a forecast, but it tells you this page is worth the work and a search with 60 impressions isn’t.Average position: the caveats that change the list
- It is the topmost position, averaged. Search Console records the highest position any link to your site held for each impression, then averages across impressions (Google’s definition). Two of your pages at 6 and 14 count as 6.
- It mixes places and devices. A city page can rank 3rd for searchers in that city and 25th elsewhere. Filter by country and device, or compare the mobile and desktop numbers, before deciding a page is on page two.
- It moves when result types change. An AI Overview takes one position in the results, and every link inside it gets that same position (Google’s note on AI features). A new set of map results or images above you also pushes the count down without your page getting worse.
- Rankings shift by day. Check the trend for the query: a page that climbed from 18 to 9 over the period needs time, not changes; a page that slid from 6 to 12 has a different problem (see content decay).
- Some queries are hidden. Search Console leaves out anonymized queries (those searched by few people), so a page’s query list never adds up to its total.
More on reading positions: keyword rankings in Search Console.
How to move them onto page one
1. Check the title and H1 use the words people searched
Compare each query’s words with the page’s title, meta description and H1. Count singular and plural as the same word, and a state code as its name (“tx” and “Texas”). If a word that shows up in many of the page’s impressions is missing from the title, add it, once and naturally. Leave out quality words like “best” or “cheap” and contact words like “phone”: they don’t make a page more relevant.
Don’t add a word for every search. DirectoryLens only suggests a title word when it accounts for at least 30% of the page’s striking-distance impressions, and never more than two. If the page is built from a template, change the template, not one page.
2. Check the page answers the search
A page at position 12 for “emergency plumber austin” that never mentions emergency or after-hours service is unlikely to climb on a title change alone. Add what the search asks for, if it is true: which listed plumbers offer 24-hour service, a filter for it, a short section on what to expect. If the page can’t honestly answer it, another page may be the better target.
3. Link to it from pages that already rank
Internal links tell Google which pages you think matter. Add links from pages that already get impressions and clicks, with anchor text that uses the searched words: from the Austin city hub to /plumbers/austin-tx, from nearby city pages, from a related guide. A page linked only from a paginated list or the sitemap is easy for Google to underrate.
4. Make sure the page can rank at all
Check that it is indexed, has the canonical you expect, and isn’t competing with another of your pages for the same search. Two of your URLs at 9 and 13 for one query often means neither will climb until you pick one; see the keyword cannibalization checker.
5. Measure it properly
Write down the date you changed each page. Wait until Google has recrawled it (URL Inspection shows the last crawl date), then compare at least two weeks after with the same number of days before. Rankings move for reasons that have nothing to do with you, so compare with similar pages you didn’t change. On a template, change half the pages and keep half as a control; see SEO A/B testing.
When to leave a striking distance keyword alone
- The search means something your page isn’t about. Ranking 14 for “plumber salary austin” on a directory page is not an opportunity.
- The page is already getting more clicks than your other pages at that position. Its title works; the lever is ranking, which may need more content or links than a quick win.
- Impressions are tiny. Fifteen impressions a month at position 8 is at most a couple of clicks even at the top.
- The ranking is still settling after a recent change or a new page.
On a directory
Striking distance keywords on a directory cluster by page type. Category-in-city pages (/plumbers/austin-tx) sit at 8 to 15 for “[service] [city]” searches; listing pages sit at 5 to 12 for “[business name] [service]” searches; city hubs pick up broad “[city] [category]” searches. Group the list by page type before you look at single URLs. If 300 city pages are all at 11 to 14 and their titles all lack the state, that is one template change.
Watch for parameter and paginated URLs in the list. If /plumbers/austin-tx?page=2 ranks 12 for a search the clean page should own, the fix is consolidation, covered in pagination and faceted navigation.
How DirectoryLens does it
Quick wins > Almost page one lists every search where a page ranks 5 to 20, has at least 20 impressions (you can pick 5, 10, 20, 50 or 100) and gets a lower click rate than your site usually gets at that position for that kind of search. It groups them by page type and by page, and estimates two numbers: visits at your usual click rate for the current position (counted only where the gap is at least 2 standard errors, so chance doesn’t inflate it), and visits at position 3.
Select a page and DirectoryLens fetches its live title, meta description and H1, lists the search words they leave out, and flags a noindex, a canonical pointing elsewhere, or a title over about 60 characters. The same data is available to Claude and ChatGPT through the Search Console MCP server.