Doorway pages

Doorway pages: Google’s policy and a test for city pages

Google treats pages built to rank for similar searches and funnel visitors elsewhere as spam. Here is the exact policy, and how to tell a real city × category page from a doorway.

Explore the live demo →

5 days free · no card needed · ends on its own

Updated

Doorway pages are pages made to rank for specific, similar searches that lead visitors to an intermediate page less useful than the real destination. Google treats them as spam under its doorway abuse policy. The textbook case is a set of city pages with the same text and only the city name swapped, all pushing visitors to one contact form.

That doesn’t make every location page a doorway. A directory page for plumbers in Austin is legitimate when it lists real plumbers in Austin that no other page on the site shows in the same way. This guide quotes the policy, turns it into a test you can run on your own city and category pages, and covers how to fix pages that fail.

The one-line test: if you replaced the city name on the page with another city, would anything else on the page have to change? If the answer is no, the page is a doorway risk. If the listings, counts, reviews and local details would all change, it is a real page about that place.

What Google’s doorway policy says

Google’s spam policies define it this way: “Doorway abuse is when sites or pages are created to rank for specific, similar search queries. They lead users to intermediate pages that aren’t as useful as the final destination.” The examples Google lists:

Two words carry most of the meaning: funnel and substantially similar. A page that exists to pass visitors along to something else, or that is a near-copy of its siblings, is the problem. A page that is itself the useful destination is not.

When Google announced a ranking change for doorways in 2015, it gave five questions to tell them apart (Google Search Central Blog, March 2015). Applied to a directory:

Google’s question, in shortWhat it means on a directory
Is the page there to funnel visitors, or is it part of the site’s experience?Does someone browsing the site land on it naturally, from the city or category page above it?
Does it target generic terms while the content is very specific?A page titled “Best plumbers in Texas” that lists three businesses in one suburb.
Does it duplicate useful aggregations that already exist on the site to capture more traffic?A second page for the same category and city, or suburb pages that repeat the metro page’s listings.
Is it made only to send affiliate traffic along without unique value?A “top 10” page where every business links to the same booking partner and nothing else is on the page.
Is it an “island”, hard to reach from the rest of the site?Pages linked only from the sitemap or a footer block of 500 city links.

Doorway pages vs landing pages vs location pages

Doorway pageLanding pageLocation page
Built forRanking for a search variantA campaign or offerA real place the business or directory covers
ContentSame as siblings, keyword swappedSpecific to the offerSpecific to the place: listings, branch details, local facts
Where it leadsFunnels to one destinationA sign-up or purchase on the pageThe listings or branch on the page itself
Linked fromSitemap, footer link blocksAds, email, the siteThe site’s own hierarchy (state → city → category)
Indexed?Shouldn’t existOften noindex for paid campaignsYes, when it has real content

See location pages SEO for how to build city and service-area pages that pass.

Is your city × category page a doorway? A practical test

Category-in-city pages are the most valuable pages on most directories, and the ones most likely to drift into doorway territory as the site grows. Run each page type through these checks. A page that fails the first two is a doorway risk no matter how good its intro text is.

  1. Real listings in that place. The page shows businesses actually located in, or genuinely serving, that city, and enough of them to be worth browsing. Pick a minimum (many directories use 3) and hold every page to it.
  2. Listings unique to the page. Ten suburbs whose pages all show the same 12 metro businesses are ten copies of one page. The suburb page needs businesses that are actually in the suburb, or it should not exist.
  3. Content that changes with the place. Listing counts, price ranges from the listings, review excerpts, opening hours, neighborhoods served, local licensing notes. Data from the listings themselves is the cheapest unique content you have.
  4. Part of a browseable hierarchy. Reachable from the state or city page and the category page, and linking down to its listings. Not an island reachable only from the sitemap.
  5. No funnel to one destination. Visitors can contact the businesses listed. A page where every button leads to one lead form or one advertiser is the funnel Google describes.
  6. One page per category and place. Not /plumbers/austin, /austin-plumbers and /plumbing-austin-tx side by side.
  7. Not a search results page in disguise. Internal search URLs such as /search?q=plumber+austin are “closer to search results than a clearly defined, browseable hierarchy”. Keep them out of the index.
SignalLegitimate city × category pageDoorway risk
ListingsAt or above your minimum, located thereNone, one, or borrowed from a nearby city
TextFacts drawn from the listings and the placeThe same paragraph with the city swapped
SiblingsEach page shows a different set of businessesSuburb pages repeating the metro list
Links inFrom city and category pagesSitemap only, or a giant footer block
Next step for a visitorContact a business on the pageOne form, one partner, or another page

Common doorway patterns on directories and local sites

Most of these start at build time, when a site generates every combination it can rather than every combination it has data for. How to build a directory website covers planning page types so this doesn’t happen, and programmatic SEO covers what makes a generated template worth indexing.

Service businesses: one page or forty?

A single business that serves many towns faces the same policy with fewer pages. Forty “Roofing in [town]” pages with the same text and the same quote form match Google’s example of pages “targeted at specific regions or cities that funnel users to one page”. Keep separate town pages only where you have something specific to show there: projects completed, crews based nearby, reviews from customers in that town, local permit rules. Fold the rest into one service-area page that names every town you cover.

How to fix doorway pages

  1. Group the pages by page type and count, for each page, its listings, its impressions in the last 90 to 180 days and whether Google indexed it. The problem is usually a whole template or a whole batch, not single pages.
  2. Improve the ones worth keeping: recruit businesses into places where people search and you have a page with too few listings, and add facts that come from those listings.
  3. Merge near-copies: 301 suburb pages that repeat the metro listings into the metro page, and keyword variants into the one page you keep.
  4. Noindex pages that may fill up later, such as a city where you are actively signing businesses. Take them out of the sitemap until they meet your minimum.
  5. Remove pages with no prospect of real content and let them return 404 or 410. An empty page that returns 200 can also show up as a soft 404.
  6. Stop generating new ones: make a page indexable only when it reaches your minimum listing count.

Expect the indexed share of the template to rise and its never-shown share to fall over the following weeks. Pruning many pages at once is a form of index bloat cleanup; track it by page type so you can tell what worked.

If Search Console shows a manual action, the Manual actions report names the issue; Google lists “Doorways” as an example under “Thin content with little or no added value”. Fix every affected page, not some of them, then request a review. Google says most reviews take several days or weeks. If there is no manual action but traffic fell during a spam update, there is nothing to request: Google’s spam update page says sites that fix the problem may see improvement once its automated systems learn that over a period of months. For the wider picture see scaled content abuse, the policy that covers mass-produced pages in general.

Find doorway risk with DirectoryLens

DirectoryLens looks at the signals above for each page type, from your Search Console data and a light crawl of a sample of your pages:

Quality signals by page type in the DirectoryLens demo: listing pages with 67% near-duplicate text marked Needs attention, and city + category pages with 63% thin pages marked Needs attention.
Quality signals per page type in the demo directory: here the city + category template has too many thin pages.

Questions

What is a doorway page in SEO?

A page created to rank for specific, similar searches that leads visitors to an intermediate page less useful than the final destination. Google treats doorway abuse as spam.

Are location pages important for SEO?

Yes, for businesses with real branches and for directories with real listings in each place, because people search with a place in mind. They become a problem only when they are copies of each other with the place name swapped.

Is a city page a doorway page?

Not if it shows real content specific to that city, such as the businesses located there, and fits in the site’s navigation. It is a doorway risk if the same text appears on every city page and it exists only to send visitors elsewhere.

Do doorway pages get a penalty?

They can lead to lower rankings through Google’s automated systems or to a manual action. Google’s Manual actions report lists “Doorways” as an example of thin content with little or no added value.

What is the difference between a doorway page and a landing page?

A landing page serves a specific campaign or offer and does its job on the page. A doorway page is one of many near-identical pages built to catch search variants and pass visitors along.

How many listings does a directory city page need?

Google sets no number. Pick a minimum that makes the page worth browsing, many directories use 3, and keep pages below it out of the index until they fill up.

How do I fix doorway pages?

Improve the pages that can have real content, merge near-copies into one page with 301 redirects, noindex pages that may fill up later, and remove the rest. Then stop generating pages that don’t meet your minimum.

See which of your page types look like doorways.

Connect Search Console, and DirectoryLens checks every page type for thin, never-shown and near-duplicate pages.

Explore the live demo →

5 days free · no card needed · ends on its own