Updated
“Alternate page with proper canonical tag” means Google found this URL, saw that its canonical tag points to a different URL, agreed, and indexed that other URL instead. It is a confirmation, not an error: in most cases you do nothing. Act only when the canonical points somewhere it shouldn’t, which takes about a minute to check in URL Inspection.
What “Alternate page with proper canonical tag” means
A canonical tag tells Google which URL is the main version of a page. When URL A says “my canonical is B” and Google accepts that, A is reported as an alternate and B gets indexed. Google’s Page indexing help says this page “correctly points to the canonical page, which is indexed, so there is nothing you need to do,” and calls being marked duplicate or alternate “usually a good thing.”
Google’s examples are AMP pages and separate mobile or desktop versions. In practice you will see the status for any URL whose canonical tag points elsewhere and that Google accepted: tracking links, sort and filter parameters, print versions and the like. Language versions are not shown here; the help page notes that alternate language pages aren’t detected by Search Console.
A typical case on a directory:
URL crawled: https://example.com/plumbers/austin-tx?sort=rating
<link rel="canonical" href="https://example.com/plumbers/austin-tx">
Result: the sorted URL is "Alternate page with proper canonical tag",
/plumbers/austin-tx is indexed.The three canonical statuses compared
Search Console has three canonical statuses that look alike and mean different things. The difference is whether you declared a canonical and whether Google went along with it.
| Alternate page with proper canonical tag | Duplicate without user-selected canonical | Duplicate, Google chose different canonical than user | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Did this URL declare a canonical? | Yes, pointing to another URL | No | Yes (often itself) |
| Did Google agree? | Yes | Nothing to agree with; Google picked one | No; Google picked a different URL |
| Which URL is indexed | The canonical you declared | The URL Google chose | The URL Google chose |
| Usually means | Working as intended | Duplicates with no canonical set | Your signals disagree, or the pages are not true duplicates |
| Action | Usually none; check the target is right | Pick the canonical and declare it, or redirect | Align your signals, or accept Google’s choice |
| Guide | This page | Duplicate without user-selected canonical | Google chose different canonical |
If the URL you are looking at has no canonical tag, you are in the wrong guide: see duplicate without user-selected canonical. If Google indexed a URL other than the one your tag names, see Google chose different canonical than user.
Ignore or act: the decision table
| What you find | Verdict | What to do |
|---|---|---|
Tracking, sort, filter or map-view URLs (?utm_source=, ?sort=, ?view=map) pointing to the clean page | Ignore | Nothing. This is the tag doing its job. |
AMP or m. pages pointing to the main page | Ignore | Nothing. |
| http, non-www or trailing-slash versions with a canonical to the right URL | Ignore, improve later | A site-wide 301 redirect is a stronger signal and stops Google crawling both. |
Paginated pages (?page=2) with a canonical to page 1 | Act | Give each page its own canonical. Google says not to use page 1 as the canonical for the series (pagination guide), or the listings on later pages lose their path in. |
| Real pages, such as listings or city pages, with a canonical to a category page or the home page | Act | A template or plugin bug. Fix the canonical so each page points to itself. |
Two different pages, one canonicalised to the other (/plumbers/round-rock-tx → /plumbers/austin-tx) | Act | If both should rank, each needs its own canonical. If one shouldn’t exist, redirect it. |
| URLs from your own sitemap | Act | List only canonical URLs in sitemaps. A sitemap full of alternates sends mixed signals. |
| The count jumped right after a release or plugin update | Act | Inspect a few new examples. A changed template often sets canonicals in bulk. |
How to check it in a minute
- In Search Console, open Indexing > Pages, click Alternate page with proper canonical tag, and scan the example URLs. Patterns jump out quickly: all
?sort=, all/amp/, or a block of listing pages that shouldn’t be there. - Click the inspect icon on a few examples. Under Page indexing, compare User-declared canonical with Google-selected canonical. For this status they match. (Every field is explained in the URL Inspection tool guide.)
- Open the canonical URL. Is it the page a searcher should land on? Inspect it too and confirm it says URL is on Google.
- If something looks wrong, view the page source and search for
rel="canonical". Check there is exactly one, in the<head>, with an absolute URL. Also check the HTTP headers for aLink: <…>; rel="canonical"header, which some servers and CDNs add.
The live test in URL Inspection doesn’t check canonical selection, so a live test can look clean while the indexed result says otherwise (URL Inspection help).
When it signals a problem
The canonical points to the wrong page
Google’s canonical troubleshooting guide names CMS and plugin bugs as a common cause: a template that sets every page’s canonical to the category, the home page or a staging domain. When Google agrees with a wrong canonical, the real page disappears from search, and Search Console files it here as if all is well. Spot it by looking at which page types appear in the examples: listings and city pages should almost never be alternates.
Paginated pages canonicalised to page 1
This is the most common mistake on directories. /plumbers/austin-tx?page=3 lists different businesses than page 1, so it isn’t an alternate of it. Give every page in the series a self-referencing canonical and keep the pages crawlable. More in pagination and faceted navigation.
The count keeps growing
Thousands of new alternates usually mean the site is generating crawlable URLs faster than it needs: filters that combine, calendar links, session IDs. The canonical tag keeps them out of the index but Google still crawls them. Google’s faceted navigation guide says a canonical may reduce crawling of those URLs over time, but robots.txt rules or filters held in URL fragments are more effective if you don’t need the filtered URLs in search.
How to set a canonical URL
Google’s canonical guide lists three signals, strongest first:
- Redirects: a strong signal that the target is canonical. Use them when the duplicate URL doesn’t need to exist, such as http and non-www versions.
- The
rel="canonical"tag, in the HTML<head>or as an HTTPLinkheader (use one, not both): a strong signal. - Sitemap inclusion: a weak signal that the listed URLs are canonical.
<!-- on https://example.com/plumbers/austin-tx and on every sorted or filtered version of it -->
<link rel="canonical" href="https://example.com/plumbers/austin-tx">Put a self-referencing canonical on the canonical page itself, use absolute URLs, link internally to the canonical URL, and don’t give the same page different canonicals through different methods. Google also says not to use noindex or robots.txt to pick a canonical.
Canonical mistakes to rule out
When the examples include pages that shouldn’t be alternates, one of these is usually behind it. Each comes from Google’s canonical guide:
- Relative URLs.
href="/plumbers/austin-tx"is supported, but Google recommends absolute URLs because relative ones cause problems later, for example when a test site gets crawled and its canonicals point at itself. - Two canonicals that disagree. A theme and an SEO plugin each print a tag, or the HTML says one URL and an HTTP header another. Google says not to specify different canonicals for the same page.
- A tag outside the head. Google only accepts
rel="canonical"in the<head>, so invalid HTML that closes the head early (a stray tag from a widget, say) can make it disappear. - JavaScript that rewrites the canonical. If a script sets or changes it, the HTML source and the rendered page disagree. Put the canonical in the HTML and leave it alone.
- A canonical to a URL that redirects, returns 404 or is noindexed. Google may then ignore your tag and pick something else, which moves the URL to Google chose different canonical.
Do alternate pages hurt rankings?
No. The alternate isn’t indexed, but the content is: it is shown under the canonical URL. Google’s canonical guide gives this as one reason to declare canonicals: signals for the individual URLs, such as links to them, are consolidated onto the preferred URL. A link someone shares to /plumbers/austin-tx?sort=rating still counts for /plumbers/austin-tx.
The cost, when there is one, is crawling. Each alternate is a URL Google may fetch. On a small site that doesn’t matter. On a directory with filters that combine into millions of URLs, it can slow the discovery of new listings, which shows up as discovered, currently not indexed.
On directory websites
Expect alternates from sort orders (?sort=rating, ?sort=distance), map and grid views, radius filters, partner tracking links (?ref=partner), and print or share versions of listings. All fine. The two patterns worth a regular look:
- Listings reachable under several paths, such as
/plumbers/austin-tx/joes-plumbingand/listing/joes-plumbing. Pick one canonical listing URL and use it in every internal link, so most of the other paths never get crawled. - Category-in-city pages pointing to the category, such as
/plumbers/austin-txwith a canonical to/plumbers. That quietly removes every local page from Google. Some directory templates do this when a page has few listings.
Check canonicals across every page type with DirectoryLens
Search Console shows up to 1,000 example URLs for this status, all page types mixed together. In DirectoryLens’s Google indexing report, the Individual pages tab lists each inspected URL with Google’s coverage state, filterable by page type, so a listing page that has become an alternate stands out; click it to see both canonicals side by side (“Google:” and “Yours:”) for every inspection. With the optional light crawl on, Thin and unused pages also counts how many sampled pages have a canonical pointing to another URL.
To check a list of URLs on demand, use the bulk index checker. For the whole picture of what each status means, see the page indexing issues guide.